Insurance
What it would cost to buy a comparable piece at retail within a reasonable time. Usually the highest of the figures.
Hire: personal property appraiser
Case file 01 / before you book an appraiser
A practical guide to professional antique appraisal: when you actually need one, how fees work, how to hire the right appraiser and how to prepare so the hour you pay for is not wasted.
Appraisal brief
Fill one in before your first call
§ 01 Purpose
The same chair can carry three honest values. A good appraiser first asks why you need the report, because the purpose sets the value definition, and the value definition sets the figure.
What it would cost to buy a comparable piece at retail within a reasonable time. Usually the highest of the figures.
Hire: personal property appraiser
The price between a willing buyer and a willing seller, both reasonably informed, neither forced to act. Used for estate returns and dividing inheritances.
Hire: USPAP compliant appraiser
When you claim a deduction of more than $5,000 for donated property, the IRS generally requires a qualified appraisal by a qualified appraiser.
See: IRS Publication 561
What it is likely to bring in its most suitable market, after selling costs. An auction estimate often answers this without a formal report.
Ask: an auction specialist first
§ 02 Decision path
Four questions, in order. Stop at the first one that settles it.
§ 03 Process
Formats differ between appraisers, but a defensible appraisal follows these six stages.
1
Intended use, intended users and the value type, agreed in writing.
2
Membership in ASA, AAA or ISA, a specialty that fits the piece and current USPAP training.
3
Hourly or flat, with an estimate of hours. Never a percentage of the value.
4
Provenance, receipts, earlier reports and clear photos of marks, labels and damage.
5
Measurements, construction, marks, condition and market research.
6
Value conclusion, method, comparables, limiting conditions and a signed certification.
§ 04 Costs
Rates vary by region, specialty and report type, so ask for the fee basis and an estimate of hours before any work starts.
| Fee basis | Typical use | Ask before you agree |
|---|---|---|
| Hourly | Single items that need research, estates | Estimated hours, and whether research and report writing are billed |
| Flat per item | One or a few pieces, online photo appraisals | Is a signed written report included, or only a verbal opinion? |
| Day rate on site | Households, collections, insurance schedules | Travel costs, number of items covered, delivery date of the report |
| Auction estimate | Selling decisions | It is not an appraisal: the auction house hopes to consign the piece |
| Percentage of value | Red flag | Professional codes and USPAP reject pay that depends on the value conclusion |
§ 05 Credentials
Search the directories of the professional societies, then confirm the appraiser's specialty matches your piece: a furniture specialist is the wrong person for Asian ceramics.
Accredited members in personal property disciplines, with a searchable directory.
Fine and decorative arts appraisers, with a find an appraiser search.
Personal property appraisers, searchable by specialty and location.
The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, published by The Appraisal Foundation.
§ 06 Pre-check
Antiqly, an app made by Obzena LLC, the company that publishes this guide, suggests what a piece is, its likely period and origin, describes visible maker's marks and shows a price range drawn from comparable secondhand listings.
Free to download on iPhone and Android. Scans need a subscription or a one time scan purchase.
§ 07 Notes
First articles in preparation
New articles on appraisal costs, credentials and preparation are published three times a week. Until the first one is out, the guide on the home page covers the essentials.